This Beach Is Mine, Bitch!
Celso Camargo , Campinas: Sep 5 2008
Made Popular Sep 5 2008
Brazil :

As I told in the previous article, the social apartheid manifests itself in various forms. Some are more discreet, some are more blatant, but the fact is that this is part of Brazilian culture. The speech may vary, can be very well disguised (full of good intentions), but the evil in the background is always the same.

This Beach Is Mine, Bitch!
Marginal Pinheiros - rich district in Sao Paulo

In this article, I will try to demonstrate how this happens in tourism, because the segregation takes different aspects, but political discourse is the same. Personally, I believe it will take a long time for this problem be solved, because it will be necessary to “rethink” the entire Brazilian society.

This Beach Is Mine, Bitch!
Grajau - poor districit in Sso Paulo

I will use slavery as an example. The abolition of slavery occurred in 1888 in Brazil, only that when it occurred, virtually there were no more slaves in Brazil, except for some places where the economy was quite late. In Sao Paulo, the coffee farmers found a workforce much cheaper, the Japanese and European immigrants. Already in 1820, Sao Paulo abolished informally the slavery and the slaves were delivered to the total abandonment. Almost no one hired them and the situation was as follows: free, but without food or housing. The government had not the slightest concern to them and society pretended they didn’t exist. In some disturbing way this is happening even today.

The cities then began to grow and to develop following this perverse logic of exclusion. The rich on one side and the others on the other. Here the middle class followed the model of the rich and began to exclude the lower middle class. And the lower middle class, the poor. Each one excluding those who could. And believe me or not, the Brazilian beaches reflect this perfectly.

The example that I’ll use to show to the reader will be the beaches of Sao Paulo (state). But do not be fooled, thinking this happens only in Sao Paulo because it happens across country, and I think a good part of the world. The difference is that many Brazilian coastal cities simply banned the poor and who is lower middle class of its beaches. And in some cases, the really rich banned the middle class of its beaches. Again the logic of exclusion.

This Beach Is Mine, Bitch!
Praia Grande

In the state of Sao Paulo, it says that there are two coastal, the north and south. Although the two are beautiful, there is a huge difference between them: the visitors and infrastructure of these places. The southern coast is for where the “farofeiros” go. “Farofeiro” is an offensive term to describe the residents of the poorest regions of Sao Paulo. These are people who earn low wages and don’t have money to rent a house or to stay in hostels or hotels and going to the beach as follows: they rent a bus that arrives in the morning and returns at night. They bring food and drink and stay the whole day on the beach singing and dancing, trying to have fun as much as possible because they know that will not last long on the beach. The most popular beach to find them is Praia Grande.

This Beach Is Mine, Bitch!
Guarujá

Only they can bring problems. Residents from these beaches claim in prefectures, accusing the “farofeiros” to cause many problems. And indeed cause. In a typical week end of the summer, some cities receive up to 1000 buses crowded that often park in places irregular, blocking residential garages. The mayors of these cities, then responded, charging ever higher fees for such buses would enter the city. Some cities have found a middle way and built and designated specific locations for such tourists. This is more typical in the southern coast.

This Beach Is Mine, Bitch!
Tombo Beach - Guarujá

However, some cities do not accept the presence of these “farofeiros” and began to charge exorbitant rates (something like US$ 2000 – the minimum wage in Brazil is US$ 200) to prevent them entering the cities. In Guaruja (beginning of the north coast), a series of measures was taken to impede the entry of this kind of tourists. There was a summer that was common on the beaches tourists remain abandoned because the city confiscated the bus in which they had arrived.

This Beach Is Mine, Bitch!
Bertioga

But the presence of “farofeiros” had already “contaminated” this city and the more affluent drove up to Bertioga, creating a “paradise” for them. The same happened in São Sebastião (San Sebastian), a place where some beaches, although public, are so unique that most visitors arriving from helicopter.

This Beach Is Mine, Bitch!
Camburi - São Sebastião

This Beach Is Mine, Bitch!
Maresias - São Sebastião

So as you can see, an imaginary line was drawn between the north and south coast in Sao Paulo. The rich on one side, the middle class in the middle and lower middle class and the poor in the other. All creating a way to segregate the other and living in a state of fear and paranoia. But do not think that there is only prejudice on the part of rich, Brazil is the land of widespread social and economic prejudice.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
2 Stars
Thanks for another insightful post,Celso. World needs more sociologists like you who look deeper into the darker side of the issues...

I guess human beings have an inherent streak to discriminate and feel one-up and better...hence all the oppression and exploitation in this world

In Brazil the prejudice is socio-economic but in countries like India there are added factors of caste and religion as well.
So its hatred that wins hands down everywhere!
2 Stars
Thanks! Again!

I guess one difference between India and Brazil is that In Brazil exists a non-official caste system, and in India it is.
3 Stars
Grace Calderon
Quezon City, Philippines
More and more, I’d like to go to Sao Paulo soon! The beaches are breathtaking. Alas, I can only go to where the poor go... LOL

Thanks for showing us the picture behind the picture of Brazil, Celso.

I suppose the country’s economic diagram is still pyramidical, with the few rich at the small tip of the pyramid.

Yes, the rich will always insist on the right to exclusivity. They feel it’s their birthright or that privilege which comes with the security of fat bank accounts.

What I am amazed with is the fact that, in Brazil, the poor do not seem to repel much this phenomenon of exclusivity. Hence, the perpetuation of social apartheid.

This kind of economic divide happens everywhere, but it is only when the oppressed and downtrodden merely accept their fate that the situation grows into apartheid proportions.

I can only speak for the Philippines. Here, though the economic divide is more than palpable and will surely never vanish, the poor do not take it sitting down.
2 Stars
That is one of the major characteristics of Brazilian society. The most popular seem not to import all this is happening in our society.

The revolutions that have happened here rarely have been initiated by the poorest.

And on the pyramid, the situation here is this: 1% of the population holds 50 of wealth.
3 Stars
Grace Calderon
Quezon City, Philippines
I truly feel sad for Brazil, Celso. But here in the Philippines, the poor can actually hobnob and mingle freely with the rich - anywhere.

The rich who remain snobbish and oppressive are written about and attacked in the press! And the rich do not like to be written about in bad light! LOL

There are much more freedom and mechanisms of freedom by which to repel the abuses of the rich over here.

Heck, we toppled a 21-year US-backed dictatorship by sheer will of PEOPLE POWER!
(Global Perspectives)
2 Stars
Grace,
Poor can be amazingly resilient in some countries. They just accept the status thrust upon them and they don’t assert against such discrimination. I often wonder how do few rich get such a power to exclude the majority?
(Global Perspectives)
3 Stars
Grace Calderon
Quezon City, Philippines
By the power of GUNS, GOONS, and GOLD, Madhuri!
(Global Perspectives)
2 Stars
In Brazil most of people wants that the government do everything. It’s a damn culture based on patrimonialism and welfarism and will take maybe 100 years to change that.
3 Stars
Grace Calderon
Quezon City, Philippines
Yes, I think that’s IT, Celso. Maybe, in Brazil, the poor are not motivated enough to repel and revolt and make an uprising. Not that they feel resigned to their helplessness, but because they are not motivated enough.

And you know what the culprit is when it comes to this attitude? Guess!!
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Hmmmmm Grace, do you want to see me thinking? Love, God (all 300), ME? Just kidding, but not so much!
2 Stars
Grace Calderon
Quezon City, Philippines
Can be all of those.

The culprit is the lethal combination of colonialism and religion.

This religious colonialism mentality makes one staid, bored, resigned to the fact, unmoved, and contented at accepting one’s reality.

And you know why?

Because God said so!
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Amen, sister!

But colonialism is one of the most important factor, as you pointed very well. First, the Portuguese and than the British and American imperialism.

The funny thing is that now, Brazil, though have friendly relationships with these countries, is not a country which follows their leadership.

So, this independent way that Brazil chose to follow, may be an indicative that things can really change in here. Of course that will not be easy, but it can happens.
2 Stars
Grace Calderon
Quezon City, Philippines
Yes, it’s bound to happen. There will always be a counterforce. Pssst... wasn’t Che a Marxist? Hehe... (nudge, nudge, wink, wink)

LOL
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Nowadays, Che and Cher are becoming the same thing: mummies from the past!

Did you like Mount Phyton?
3 Stars
Grace Calderon
Quezon City, Philippines
By comparison over here, 1% of population holds 99% of wealth. But there is a thriving middle class that is educated. And there seems to be a level playing field when it comes to education and skills capability.

The poor cannot really, by themselves, topple the prevailing social order. It is the educated and skilled middle class that initiates a revolution, with the help of the poor by sheer volume.
2 Stars
This is really something! When the middle class cares about the country, they can make real changes. This kind of mentality here is just beginning. :(
3 Stars
Grace Calderon
Quezon City, Philippines
And on this note, let me add another example. It is also the stark absence of an educated middle class that makes Afghanistan the way it is right now and for many years now, and for many more years to come.

The divide is so wide between the powerful and powerless. There is no bridge between the two whatsoever.
(Global Perspectives)
3 Stars
Grace Calderon
Quezon City, Philippines
Well, there now, you’ve found your calling, Che! LOL
(Global Perspectives)
2 Stars
But Grace, thanks to consumerism, middle class is too busy adding personal assets and becoming neo-rich. They are getting trapped in credit woes as well. It’ll take some time even for skilled and educated middle class to get away from such trappings and initiate a change!
(Global Perspectives)
2 Stars
The Brazilian middle class is too busy shopping in malls!
3 Stars
Grace Calderon
Quezon City, Philippines
You’re right, Madhuri. The middle class is bound to fit the mold of the rich sooner or later down the road.

But there will still be a few among the middle class shoppers whose feet will get tired shopping, will come home, think while in their dark bedrooms, and come to the conclusion that consumerist spending can be boring eventually.

And these might, just might, think of the status of those who cannot even enter the malls, much less shop.
(Global Perspectives)
3 Stars
Ramesh Balam
Pune, India
Who is the bitch in the article?
3 Stars
Grace Calderon
Quezon City, Philippines
Ok, Ok, Ramesh, I’ll claim it for now. LOL
(Global Perspectives)
2 Stars
If someone that don’t ”belong” to an specific beach. The poor in Maresias, for instance, or the rich in Praia Grande.
2 Stars
Ramesh Balam
Pune, India
Thanks Grace. Please do not accept the unacceptable. I am sure no one in his senses would ever call you as such.
(Global Perspectives)
4 Stars
Jaiyant Cavale
Bangalore, India
Celso! I”m coming to Brazil and visiting all the beaches! And the ones for the poor just like Grace would.. It is indeed perverse to stop people from visiting beaches that are there for everyone to use.. I’ll tell you what happens here.. Most of the beautiful beaches are bought by resorts and 5 star hotels and the common man and the dogs (you find a lot of canines on indian beaches) go to the dirtier ones. Segregation in the Indian society is starker but is very different because there are so few Rich people. And here, the class is not determined by money but by various other factors too. A really poor person can look down upon someone rich and treat him like a slave.. And that happens here..
1 Stars
Hehehehe! I doubt you could get to stay in one of the poor’s beaches, unless you want to take some Brazilian parasites home, like ”geographic bug”!
1 Stars
Jayashree
bangalore, India
Hmpfs. You can all go to the poor man’s beach. I’m going to the richest of the richest. Hey Celso, what about nude beaches? Any segregation there, too? Like maybe hot guys up north and ugly guys down south?
1 Stars
Ramesh Balam
Pune, India
I have seen a beach for nudes in Goa. I don’t know whether that still exists or not.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
There are nude beaches, but I never went to one of those. But I guess they cannot discriminate people because of the size of...you can imagine!
2 Stars
Jayashree
bangalore, India
LOL! Welcome back, Celso!
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Chandni
Allahabad, India
In India too we have many, many beautiful beaches and there are hundreds of secret beaches in the country that are not known or visited by tourists. Such places are any lover's fantasy. Try visiting a few of those remote coastal villages and you would know what I am trying to say.
1 Stars
Ramesh Balam
Pune, India
Lovers may kiss or fondle at any place. Some try sex, if you mean that. Incidently, those beaches are called virgin beaches.
(Global Perspectives)
2 Stars
Neha
Gandhinagar, India
My uncle worked in the Military Engineering Services and was posted in a military base in a place called Gopalpur-on-Sea in Orissa. It was a beautiful place to be. After my 10th boards, I once visited the place and my cousin who was the same age as me rode me to a nearby village some 7ks from the place which was already a tourist attraction. It had one lovely small beach that had no visitors. Looked like paradise to me.
1 Stars
Vijay
Kota, India
”Virgin” beaches,is it a proper word for such beaches where all kind of sexual activities,frat parties goes on uniteruptedly.
2 Stars
Oscar
Oaxaca, Mexico
Dammit Celso,
I’ve been struggling, really searching for who I truely am.. I was looking more towards a modern day, educated Divine Mexican Warrior, but the truth has been told.. I am nothing more than a lowly Brazilian Farofeiro trapped in a Mexican god-like body...Thanks for bursting my bubble, Compadre. Power to the people.
1 Stars
LOL! ”Mexican god-like body”? You are so modest! LOL!
Add your Comment