Welcome to Hell
Celso Camargo , Campinas: Aug 25 2008
Made Popular Aug 25 2008
Brazil :

Can you imagine yourself living in hell? Can you imagine you, your family and your friends having to work and study in a place that was completely taken by violence and hate ? Well, not only I can imagine, but I lived there for 13 years. The name of this place that was forgotten by God and the devil? Sao Paulo.

The 80’s and 90’s were the worst decades in the Sao Paulo’s history. There was a union of local, national and international problems that transformed the city in the worst nightmare for any human being who despises violence. What I testify was frightening (as corpses in the streets and a cold blood execution), and even then was not the worst thing was happening. It was only the tip of the iceberg.

Welcome to Hell
Downtown

The homicide rate in some districts was over 400 per hundred thousand inhabitants. The police killed over 2000 men, at a time when it died more than 10 thousand people in Sao Paulo annually. The unemployment rate among young people was above 25% and the city was taken by slums. It was estimated that 5 million people used to live in those places. There was no more beauty, there was no more reason, there was no more hope. No matter where you looked, the only thing to be seen was poverty, pollution, violence and unemployment.

This was the portrait of the richest city in Brazil until six years ago. Before pointing out the main causes for these problems I must remind the reader that this article is not scientific, is based only on my personal experience and analysis. The main causes that I’ll be pointing are: a disorganized migration process and corruption in different levels of government. Of course there are others, but I’m just one human being, not two, three or ten, the rest is for when I be able to write.

Migration

One of the most common things that you hear about Sao Paulo is that the city is ugly, does not have a face of anyone, a city which appears to be a huge pile of buildings completely impersonal, sinister and intimidating. Well, for those who do not know a little bit of architecture and that don’t repair in people that is true. The fact is that Sao Paulo is not a homogenous city, is a city composed of other cities. Cities that the Italians, Japanese, Portuguese, Spanish, Germans, Jews, Syrians, Lebanese, British and especially Brazilians have been building over the twentieth century (and rebuilding in this century). This not to mention the indigenous tribes that managed to resist the so-called “progress”, but this is a subject for another article ...

Finally, is a mixture so crazy and so complex that many actually see, but prefer to ignore. Nevertheless the most important is that each one of these groups of immigrants who came to Sao Paulo was able to find space to build a neighborhood or even a district that had its face. In Liberdade (“freedom”) is still common to hear people speaking Japanese. In Higienópolis, Hebrew. Moóca, Italian.

Welcome to Hell
Liberdade

At the 50’s, however, serious problems started to arise and the city was growing at a disorderly pace. But, it was from that decade that more people began arriving to Sao Paulo. It was millions of “nordestinos” (people from Brazilian Northeast) that even today are arriving in Sao Paulo. The situation became worse when, at the 70’s, the oil crises happened and the economy started to get bad, very bad. In addition to stagnation, the inflation was out of control. In the 80’s things deteriorated further nationally due to drought in northeastern Brazil, which lasted 5 years in some states. The nordestinos wanted to escape from the semi-arid poverty, but instead of find opportunities to start a new life, they faced the poverty of living in Sao Paulo. Extreme poverty and cold (Sao Paulo gets very cold during the winter - duh - with beggars dying on the streets).

The slums began to appear everywhere, sometimes in just one week. It happened successive invasions of buildings and land and destruction of protected environmental areas. Moreover, many people built houses in places of danger and the inevitable happened: when the summer came, it was common to see in the news desperate people who have lost family members and all personal possessions in flood and in landslide (in Sao Paulo in the summer it rains as if the world was ending). It was official: there was no where to escape misery here in Brazil.

Welcome to Hell
Paraisópolis, one of the biggest slums

The same was happening with the medium and large cities in the interior of the state. Some small towns have decided”to protect” themselves of migrants expelling them through little subtle ways. Of course, now it’s the time to talk about the skinheads. Fanzines were distributed free and lower middle-class white kids started to like the idea, being seduced by a aggressive and opportunistic “ideology”, and hundreds began to make fatal victims throughout state. A new and improved violence had arise and until today these groups are killing people, although, after a terrorist attack against a synagogue in Campinas, these groups have become more discreet.

However, the cruelty does not stop there. Above I said that the city of Sao Paulo is composed of several cities, each with their own ways. Perhaps the only thing equal / homogeneous in Sao Paulo was the poverty in the periphery. Although there are slums in almost all districts, is on the distant periphery that lives this giant mass of migrants, with the exception of those living in “vertical slums” in the central areas. The biggest “vertical slum” building was the Treme-Treme (literally Shake-Shake) in which used to live 10 thousand people.

Welcome to Hell
Treme-Treme

And the worst part is coming. The crack, which was reached at the 80’s, dominated the periphery and a specific area in the centre known as Crackland. The killings were constant and in one weekend, 50 man/kids were murdered. At the same time, as they hadn’t hospitals in these areas, the infant mortality rate was very, very high. Most schools remained open only for 2 hours in certain periods, because teachers were to scared to go to work or because the drug dealers called to school saying that “it’s time to close”. And the police, what the police did? At that time, the police in Sao Paulo was the most brutal in Brazil. The record of police killing is about 2000 in one year, only in Sao Paulo. And, when the police didn’t go to those places, nobody removed the bodies from the streets.

Finally, children and adolescents were massacred in a hellish pace by themselves or by the police. There were no schools, or hospitals, or jobs, there was only crack and guns pointed out to all sides. Another detail that can not be forgotten is with respect to the color of those who died in these places. There was one thing in common, they were all “non-whites”.

The white ones was being killed in the middle class districts, victims of robberies and kidnappings. The tension between the classes (and the colors) was increasing and the future was more uncertain and more sinister than ever. The rich people began to move to closed condominiums, high excluses places to really rich people. The biggest example is Alphaville in which live more than 30 thousand people. How to walk around in such insecure city? The richest began to buy helicopters. The upper middle class, armoured cars. But what about the “rest”? What the middle class could do? What the poorest could do? Killing each other wasn’t the solution and it was obvious that wait for governmental action was useless, because all spheres of government get everybody disappointed. Big time!

Welcome to Hell
Pinheiros, middle class district

It was then that someone had a great idea “let’s stop waiting for the government and start doing something for our city?” And thus different sectors of society have begun to mobilize to start rebuilding the city, a task that is only in the beginning, but that is changing dramatically the lives of millions of Brazilians who live in there. So, once again, migrants and paulistanos are reinventing Sao Paulo, trying to build a future for themselves. For how long? I don’t know, however I really hope that this lasts for a long time because it’s the only option.

In a few days I’ll publish the other part of the article about corruption and urban decay of Sao Paulo.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
4 Stars
Sandhya
Shimla, India
Hi,You have used very powerful pics, which made me to read whole article.Will look forward for other part of the article
3 Stars
Thank you. As soon as my brain back to normal, I’ll be publishing the other part.
4 Stars
Grace Calderon
Quezon City, Philippines
I guess those people who started to rebuild the city are the civil society. This group can indeed do a lot when all the members put their hearts and minds to it. Urban rehabilitation is an extremely tough task.

But what can make this city recover faster is still the local government. A tough mayor or governor that means business can expedite the work of civil society tenfold. It’s still government that has all the tools needed for urban reform.

But, of course, that rests on tons of political will.
4 Stars
Yes, the change came from civil society and the local government was pressured to make the most different types of social projects and urban planning.
4 Stars
Sasmita
pune, India
But Celso I think Sao Paulo is also known for some good reasons as well. Well, as I have not seen the place I fear to visit even if I get a chance in future. So you have the experience of Hell in Sao Paulo? The way you have described the place is heart-breaking, I feel like crying really. Your images are aptly choosen to support the subject. Good!
3 Stars
Thank you. This was the portrait of the city at the years 80’s and 90’s. Things have changed a lot, for example, the number of people living in slums fell from 5 to 2 million in recent years.
5 Stars
Oscar
Oaxaca, Mexico
Celso,
Incredible story and pictures. I feel as if my country is just getting to where Sao Paulo WAS. I hope, we as a Nation, find the strength to ”reverse fate” and begin reconstruction on all levels as well..
Un gran saludo amigo!!!
4 Stars
It is very sad when we see a place we love degrade rapidly. The bottom of the pit that reached Sao Paulo is an example of the incompetence, omission and corruption of our leaders can cause. And Oscar, I sincerely hope that Mexico does not become what it was Sao Paulo, as are brands that are very painful.


Un abrazo amigo!
4 Stars
Jaiyant Cavale
Bangalore, India
Sao Paulo is the symbol of modern urban civilization. There couldn’t be a better example for urban growth and expansion. Most cities of this magnitude have their problems with crime, mafia, poverty and other social problems at a greater rate than smaller cities. The fact that Sao Paulo is in a developing country worsens the condition. Bombay is like a still uglier twin of Sao Paulo.. Expect we lack helicopter taxis....
3 Stars
Don’t bother, Jaiyant, I’ll send you a helicopter.

But what you said is true. Large cities in developing countries can be a really monstrosity, a gift from the devil himself. However, if Sao Paulo could find a way out, any other city can (though this change in Sao Paulo occurred because of the richness of the city, other Brazilian metropolis are sinking rapidly, but with a difference, they do not have a tenth of the wealth that Sao Paulo has).
3 Stars
Grace Calderon
Quezon City, Philippines
I believe, Sao Paolo will overcome the attendant challenges of urban expansion and cosmopolitanism. I due time, it will learn the lessons of other urban models and emulate the best practices in urban management.

It will just take tremendous will on the part of local government and an ever invigorated civil society.

There should be a Sao Paolo Metropolitan Commission that’s like a little government within the local government.
3 Stars
This type of action exists, but in a decentralized and participation of local government there. But because of the number of social projects that are being developed / implemented, the participation of government ends being reduced. A kind of privatization of the social sector of the city is what is happening in Sao Paulo.

However, the mayor come up with very good ideas, like the ”Clean City” Law, a very unusual law that banned advertisements in the city.
3 Stars
Grace Calderon
Quezon City, Philippines
Sao Paolo is well on its way to greatness! It’s just a little too difficult because it is a huge urban location.

I remember a few years back, I read in some news, when Lee Kwan Yew was proudly presenting the achievements in urban development that Singapore has achieved, then the premier of China rebutted and said, to this effect: ”Oh sure yes, I can do the same if I were the mayor of Shanghai.” Of course, it was clear to the audience of that conference that the Chinese leader meant that Singapore was able to do it quickly because it wasn’t as big as China, and Shanghai of much smaller size can do the same.

I wonder if Shanghai, indeed, was able to do the same. LOL
(Global Perspectives)
2 Stars
I guess, as you said, these huge urban locations are very hard to administrate. Problems don’t go away easily and it’s required a lot of ”social” capital. And laws rarely resolves something.

The only place I know here in Brazil that was able to get unbelievable achievements was Ribeirao Preto (medium city in Sao Paulo state, with 500 thousands inhabitants), but it’s a very, very rich city (it’s the Brazilian ethanol capital with a very high GDP per capita - up to $30,000).

But the arrogance of the Chinese leader makes me wonder what will happen with Shangai now.
2 Stars
Celso...
Thats an optimistic post! Nice pictures...
Civil society can do a lot only if government doesn’t put roadblocks.
I am sure Sao Paolo will magically re- organise itself over and over again, inspite of all roadblocks. The basic spirit of inhabitants is positive. Thats a vital point.
2 Stars
Thank you!

This is true, the situation was unbearable and it was necessary a series of actions to start to change it.
2 Stars
I think for any change, the initiation of the process is important...right momentum takes it forward...
Strength of civil society lies in numbers and its great that they patiently trying to move forward. And its rare to find a Mayor who takes sensible decisions keeping city in mind.
It takes efforts to rise above immediate self-interest and do something for our environment and city.
(Global Perspectives)
2 Stars
You are absolutely right!

I don’t know exactly when it started, but a decisive moment was when a Irish Catholic priest decided to take community members to a cemetery in Sao Paulo, showing them what was happening.

Little by little, more and more people, from intellectuals to billionaires, from very poor people to socialites, started to get seriously worried about the situation. And so begun the pressure on Mayors and Governors and the result is a change beyond any sociological explanation.

You’re absolutely right in point at the strength of civil society. And about the timing? Who would imagine that a visit to a cemetery could make such difference?
2 Stars
Phoenix always rises from the ashes!
(Global Perspectives)
3 Stars
Photo of just the Treme Treme alone is very moving. I think this piece is written a little too forcefully though–even for an editorial. You present the evidence, and let the reader decide for themselves whether or not Sao Paulo is hell.
2 Stars
To keep impersonality on this topic is something very difficult for me because it brings with it some of my best and worst memories of my childhood and adolescence. But it was good you have warned me, because now I can prevent the ”Latin spirit” come to the surface.
2 Stars
Alexis
Paris, France
In some districts the rate of homicide is over 400 per 1000? Are you crazy? Almost half the population is murdered a year? That way who fills in the gaps? Why would people move in to such places? This is unbelievable.
1 Stars
400 per HUNDRED 1000.
3 Stars
Richard
Wellington, New Zealand
Sao Paulo is a great, great city. It is a symbol of modern civilisation as Jaiyant said. The problems related to crime in Sao Paolo is typical of a rapidly growing city in a developing country in general, and Latin America in particular. I am not too surprised.
3 Stars
Kate
Amsterdam, Netherlands
Celso Camargo:

Let me first congratulate you on this wonderful article. It is not always the rest of the world get insights of cities of South America. I have learned quite a few things here like some high murder rates. Very strong writing and the pictures you put are awesome. Thanks for all the information.
1 Stars
Anna T
NYC, United States
I like this-migration as it is by M. Kerjman, Australia, UAE stuff:

http://mkwrk2.instablogs.com/entry/in-the-realm-of-pride/
Add your Comment